Arkin wrote:Peter I think you did a great job. I dont get what the amtgard guys are saying about what people are most likely to do when your in there face.
I think the basic sentiment was that there are several more considerations for the theories presented that were not accounted for in the lessons; I further went on to postulate that I don't think Peter is incapable of figuring those situations out, which means he probably has not encountered them. I don't know Peter, so I could be wrong about that. I then said that, in my experience with Belegarth, the average fighter tends to have a small repertoire of shots. Derian suggested that the most common are the high cross, hip wrap, and arm chop; I would agree with his assessment.
Its almost like they think there going to have a hour to think about what they are doing before you close. I agree with them to a point because I like fighting from a distance, but you can move forward quicker then someone can move backwards. So as long as you take a couple blocks then step in you can "grind" all day.
I find that I generally have ample time to consider my options in both Amtgard and Belegarth. With some practice and training you will find that thinking critically while you fight is both feasible and highly advantageous. In any given situation, the guy with the plan almost always wins over the guy just reacting.
There weapons are also lighter so there average fighter might have a bigger shot selection but idk.
I had no issues translating my shot repertoire from Belegarth and Amtgard. I think the issue is far more to do with proper body mechanics and force generation than with weapon weight. A light Amtgard weapon tends to be 7oz, while mine are about 12.5oz.