I actually agree with Brutus 100% on this. Factual knowledge shouldn't be the only standard for being able to answer. Equally important is a calm demeanor and experience.
I say we nominate five or six veterans who are well known for their knowledege of the rules and a tendancy not to flame. For example people like Kyrax, Eoric, Owen, Freyson, or Kegg.
A lot of the newer people are upset because they will be excluded from this. I'm sorry, but experience and having heralded and checked weapons at twenty or more events is something that should be required. Just because you know the rules on paper doesn't always mean you will know how they apply in a real world situation. I don't think anyone who has been in less than five years should even be considered.