by Kyrian » Sun Apr 08, 2012 1:59 pm
If you can, try out both styles of shields. Myself, personally, I prefer strapped shields but that's only because I prefer using offensive shield work and I've found that strapped shields tend to give you more control when you're edging or punching with the shield. You can still use these types of techniques with a punch shield but with only the one point of contact between my arm and the shield, it just doesn't feel as stable to me. Punches, though, can be much more effective at controlling range since you can hold them farther from you, tend to be more maneuverable, and extend the cone of defense out in front of the shield. A person has to get past the shield in order get to you. I've also found that punches can be more effective against flails because you can hold the shield farther away from your body. One of the downsides of punch shields is that they are far more susceptible to being manipulated especially at the corners. A spear can stab at a corner and the punch will open up like a door. So, to sum up, each type of shield has its good and bad points. You could also consider purchasing a punch shield and then running some straps through it so you can use it as both a punch and strap.
"...change requires action, it doesn't just happen. Define your actions by how you think the game should be, not how the game is. The game will follow."--Big Jimmy